Skip to content

What's best: SIM only or pay monthly?

Article author's profile picture
Written by  Jessica Bown
5 min read
Updated: 05 Nov 2026

Choosing a new phone contract can feel overwhelming. With so many deals, features and bits of small print to consider, it’s not always clear where to start.

How to choose the right mobile phone contract

The key is to focus on what you actually need. Once you understand how you use your phone, it becomes much easier to narrow down your options and find the right deal.

woman on phone

Start with your phone usage

Before comparing contracts, think about how you use your phone day to day.

  • Do you stream videos, scroll social media and rely on mobile data?

  • Or do you mostly use your phone for calls and the occasional message?

Your usage will help determine whether you need lots of data, unlimited calls, or just a basic plan. Getting this right means you won’t overpay for extras you don’t need — or run out of allowance when you need it most.

Finding the right fit

The best contract is one that matches your usage without wasting money.

Choose wisely and you’ll avoid paying for unused data or facing extra charges for going over your limits.

If you’re unsure which option suits you best, don’t worry — we’ll walk you through the main types of mobile contracts.

SIM-only deals

What is a SIM-only deal?

A SIM-only deal gives you a SIM card with a monthly allowance of data, minutes and texts — but no handset.

How they work

You pay a fixed monthly fee for your allowance. These plans are usually simple and often cheaper than contracts that include a phone.

SIM-only deals can start from as little as £5 a month, often including generous data and unlimited calls and texts. Contract lengths vary, with options ranging from 30-day rolling plans to 12- or 18-month agreements.

Why choose SIM-only?

SIM-only deals are a great option if you already have a phone and want to keep costs down. You can also use them with new SIM-free phones.

  • Flexible: Many plans are rolling monthly, so you can switch or cancel easily

  • Affordable: No handset cost keeps prices low

  • Accessible: Some deals don’t require a credit check

Things to consider

  • You’ll need to supply your own phone

Pay-monthly phone contracts

What is a pay-monthly contract?

A pay-monthly contract includes the cost of a new handset as well as your data, minutes and texts.

Spreading the cost

Instead of paying upfront for a phone, you spread the cost over a set period. This used to generally be the same as your contract term, say 12 or 24 months. However, providers have reacted to rising smartphone costs by offering longer-term handset repayment agreements. Both O2 and EE, for example, offer repayment terms of up to 48 months, while Vodafone EVO device plans range from three to 36 months.

These deals clearly separate handset and airtime costs, so you can see exactly what you’re paying for and for how long. With EE Flex Pay, for example, you can sign up to a 24-month airtime contract alongside a 48-month device agreement and choose to settle the device balance at any time.

You can compare the cost of this approach with a SIM-only contract by adding the cost of the handset (upfront or over the repayment term) to the amount you pay for monthly airtime. You will, however, need the cash available to buy a new phone outright to get the same handset on a SIM-only deal.

Why choose pay-monthly?

  • No upfront handset cost

  • Predictable monthly payments

  • Perks and incentives (like rewards or freebies)

Things to consider

  • You’ll usually need to pass a credit check

  • Contracts can be long – especially if you choose an expensive handset deal, which can make it harder to switch

  • You may pay more overall compared to buying a phone outright

Pay-as-you-go (PAYG)

How does pay-as-you-go work?

With pay-as-you-go, there’s no contract. You simply top up your phone with credit and use it as needed.

Some providers also offer bundles that give you a set amount of data, calls and texts for a fixed price.

Why choose PAYG?

This option works well if you don’t use your phone often or want maximum flexibility.

  • No contract or monthly commitment

  • No credit check required

  • Good for light users

Things to consider

  • You’ll need your own handset

  • Costs per minute, text or data can be higher

  • Heavy users may find it more expensive than other options

Final thoughts

There’s no one-size-fits-all mobile contract. The right choice depends on how much you use your phone, whether you need a new handset, and how much flexibility you want.

Take a moment to assess your habits, compare your options, and you’ll be in a much better position to find a deal that truly works for you.

Author

Article author's profile picture

Jessica Bown

Insurance expert

Jessica Bown is an award-winning freelance journalist and editor who has been writing about personal finance for almost 20 years. She started her career on the Money team at the Daily Express, then...

Author's linkedin page
More about Jessica
Find out more
Compare deals