home
in

Women drive a good deal on insurance

Last post Wed, Dec 10 2008, 8:33 AM by Grommet. 26 replies.
Page 1 of 2 (27 items)   1 2 Next >
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  Wed, Dec 10 2008, 8:33 AM

    Re: Women drive a good deal on insurance

    The original premise of this thread was that girl only insurance companies are cheaper. That is not what I have found when looking for cover on behalf of my wife. In fact all of the companies mentioned in this thread were at least 50% more than the lowest quote.

    I suspect that the girls are having the wool pulled over their eyes and insurance companies can spot you from a mile off, the same way a mechanic can! (Yes, that is a generalisation - my wife assists me with bleeding the hydraulic lines and passing cups of tea on a regular basis and knows how to cope with understeer in a rear wheel drive car, unlike a great many male drivers.)

    Why not find out who owns that girl only company and check out what they offer in their standard offerings, you may be suprised.

    • Post Points: 5
  •  Thu, Apr 10 2008, 5:35 PM

    Re: Women drive a good deal on insurance

    When do women pay for anything themselves? As far as I can they just use their husband's income while they pretend that they have 'child care' responsibilities that stop them getting a job but don't stop them going out and gettng drunk.

    • Post Points: 20
  •  Thu, Apr 10 2008, 5:32 PM

    Re: Women drive a good deal on insurance

    They may, of course, also be wanting equal pay with the right to take six months maternity leave off every year. I'm ashamed to be woman. They are such a waste of space.
    • Post Points: 5
  •  Thu, Apr 10 2008, 5:12 PM

    Re: Women drive a good deal on insurance

    Ageism and sexism all rolled into one service. Man, I love this country. If only there was some kind of law to protect people like me (I'm a young male) against this.....oh wait.

    • Post Points: 35
  •  Thu, Apr 10 2008, 5:03 PM

    Re: Women drive a good deal on insurance

    Are women allowed to drive now?

    They'll be wanting to vote next........

    • Post Points: 41
  •  Sun, Mar 16 2008, 1:05 AM

    Re: Women drive a good deal on insurance

    Women are not better drivers than men. Women just do less driving than men. Women are not, on the whole, particularly good at doing things for themselves. Its much easier to complain and whinge and moan.

    • Post Points: 20
  •  Sun, Mar 16 2008, 1:00 AM

    Re: Women drive a good deal on insurance

    Actually, despite being female, I do have to agree.

    Men are generally just much better people than women. I am always amazed at what a waste of space most women still remain.

    • Post Points: 5
  •  Sat, Feb 02 2008, 8:10 PM

    Re: Women drive a good deal on insurance

    Laura.Brewer:I think its great that car insurance is cheaper for girls!. For myself, i found that Girl Motor was the cheapest quote for me and gave me far better deal, women are much better drivers, i agree with one of the comments on here that us women tend to have more smaller crashes the odd bump in the car park and men tend to have big crashes and write off cars ect.. sorry men but its true!

    Yes its great for blokes too! Be a second driver under a womans name, not only do you save money but if you crash its her fault!


    welcome back zoe, yet under a new alias. Lol, I seriously find this so funny that ur obsessed with this car insurance

    issuse. Well for starters in 2007 the average women paid £65 less then men and old women actually pay more then men

    (in the same period men earned 17% more the women £6,000 in an average full time job

    which rises to over £40,000 in senior positions). So Yes wow a huge £65, which you can use to buy a good supply of always. yes a massive amount worth

    making car insurance threads about? And when you consider that men pass with an average of 12 lessons less then females and women are much more likely to fail on first attempt (http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/article513993.ece)

    then men, quite a nice saving for men £65 seems a little silly


    Also for instance women pay more for health insurance, get lower pensions are paid less, and in general female goods e.g. clothes, makeup, feminine toiletries,

    haircuts etc cost women more but no one is making threads about this, well why would they its stupid and childish and more importatnly a massive waste of time!!


    Next did you think about this statement? Do men pay actually more? In some countries yes in many no and in many countries insurance isn't even required. And for the 2 million uninsured UK drivers, I don't think insurance costs are a problem, and in many countries were women are not even allowed to drive (and im not talking about one or two villages im talking about literally hundreds of millions of women directly (by law) banned from driving (and if you include other countries were women are "indirectly" (by the social and economic status of women) that number skyrockets so

    I doubt gender plays an important issue in those countries!


    And when do actually men pay for car insurance? - Teenagers is the only significant time,

    and who normally pays for teenagers insurance - mum and dad i.e. You so it doesnt even affect those men, it affects you. After pay about the same and old women actually pay more then old men (and at the same time women receive lower pensions then men). And as I said men just simply get insured with a female.


    So i dont understand, why the obsession about car insurance? No one really cares. men even created female insurance and even the marketing for Shiellas wheels is run by a man – Adrian Webb. If people really did care they would do something about it so seriously I don't mean this to be poky, but really what is the cause of this insurance obsession. If your so obsessed with car insurance then why dont you look at health, personal income, annuities and pensions all where women pay more then men.

    Please kindly answer my question

    • Post Points: 50
  •  Thu, Jan 31 2008, 11:58 AM

    Re: Women drive a good deal on insurance

    "Woman are much better drivers"... Our survey says Ehh Ehhhhh. Woman are NOT safer drivers, and as already pointed out they DO crash more but at lower speeds, meaning they have CHEAPER (not less claims). Also mens car tend to be of a higher value, cost more to repair and the cost of insurance reflects this. Found this thread quite entertaining, especially the first post in which the woman thought it was magic that women pay less for car insurance. I think it's magic how the guy who posted after her burst her bubble =)
    • Post Points: 5
  •  Thu, Jan 31 2008, 10:03 AM

    Re: Women drive a good deal on insurance

    I think its great that car insurance is cheaper for girls!. For myself, i found that Girl Motor was the cheapest quote for me and gave me far better deal, women are much better drivers, i agree with one of the comments on here that us women tend to have more smaller crashes the odd bump in the car park and men tend to have big crashes and write off cars ect.. sorry men but its true!
    • Post Points: 56
  •  Thu, Jan 24 2008, 7:38 PM

    Re: Women drive a good deal on insurance

    Ok....

    Most women only really drive on school runs or to the supermarket. Both of which rarely involve going above 30mph.

    When a man is in the car with a woman, the chances are that it is the man who is the driver.

    When a man and a woman are on the dual carriage way or motorway, it is usually the man who is the driver.

    We should all be able to agree that:

    1. Men drive on faster roads more often

    2. Men drive further than women

    and if we agree with the above 2 statements, then 3. Men spend longer driving than women.

    As such, it wouldn't surprise me that men have more accidents than women.

    • Post Points: 5
  •  Sun, Jan 13 2008, 9:31 PM

    Re: Women drive a good deal on insurance

    Where did you get the "74%" figure from? And could you just clarify what you meant in point 5 - ie what is "rapidly changing"? As to the reason why male drivers kill and maim and seriously injure nine/ten times as many people as female drivers, I would suggest that testosterone and machismo and bloody mindedness play a significant part in it, and with younger male drivers, also showing off and trying to impress and self image. As to your last point, I would rephrase it thus: 'simply because THEY ARE NOT STUPID ENOUGH TO DO SO' !!
    • Post Points: 5
  •  Sat, Jan 12 2008, 9:41 PM

    Re: Women drive a good deal on insurance

    ye so wot is ur point, my point was: 1) I dont care about gender issues as i dont have the mentality like the thread starter 2) However, since she brings it up the statistics, the pass rates, crash rates data and more importantly the acheivements of men in terms of jobs, invention, maintenance and championships MEN ARE BETTER DRIVERS,

    you seem to be bogged down about this car insurance issue = better driving. Well news for you mate, teachers pay cheaper insurance then doctors who pay less the medical students who pay more then lawyers! are you saying teachers are better drivers then doctors because of insurace price or better then lawyers? HAHAH LOL do u see your lack of prior logic? Old women pay more for car insurance then old men! are old men better then women? Women pay more for health insurance so does that mean they are unhealtheir then men? Red and blue cars are more likely to be stolen? why? because red and blue are the worst cars no simply because red and blue are the most popular cars in the UK. red sports cars are most likely to be caight speeding? are red cars worse no! more high performance cars are red, and people who tend to drive red cars are often the "wow look at my red porsche types". Women get lower annuties does that mean old women are not worth it? NO of course not. to end this argument once and for all:

    INSURANCE COST = TOTAL PREMIUMS BY YOUR GROUP/CLASS (divided by) NUMBER OF PEOPLE IN YOUR CLASS simple as that nothing to do with who is better IT DOESN'T EVEN HAVE TO DO WITH WHO CRASHES MORE - as (Churchill's analysis of male and female driving records also shows that over a lifetime women are likely to have more accidents, an average of 9.5, compared to 8.2 for men. But in terms of the cost to insurers, women's crashes tend to be at lower speeds and less expensive SO IN INSURANCE EYES THEY ARE BETTER RISK

    so lets look at this formula for insurance:

    men have entirely different patterns of driving, they are much less likey to travel with children so dont drive as slow, they have more powerful, expensive and higher spec cars, they have 74% more milage and there is nearly 3 million more male drivers. 82% of men compared to only 61% of female drive. Women have much shorter journeys and less milage and are more likely to take children. Men drive much more frequently after 10pm then women and this is THE DRIIVING KILL FIELD TIME when most of these deaths, accidents happen COMPARING FIGURES IS LIKE APPLES AND GRAPES!!

    The main factors in what determines male insurance prices:

    1) Men get paid more - 2006 men got paid 17% more then women (£6000/year more which in senior positions rose t £42000) and please dont bring up the sexism issue here (do that in anoother thread), men get paid more because they work more and work in harder and more dangerous jobs and for crap loads more not simply because they were men (if women got paid less simply for being men then dont you think all the companies would fire men to save money?)

    2) Because of this men own more cars then women and also more liscences (possiblly due to work habits too?) only 61% of females compared to 82% of males have a liscene and men have a whopping 74% more milage then women. (this is rapidly chaning as more women are driving which will lead to mroe crashes). As a result many women are simply second drivers on mens cars so their crashes are given to mens policies.

    3) Simply because men have more cars and more milage they are more likely to have their cars stolen, vandilised or be the victim of hit and runs, and insurance scams simply because there are more male cars.

    4) As a result of this more policies are in mens names so regardless of who crashes the policy owner (the male is more likely to pay). However this is RAPIDLY changing in the past decade alone there has been a one third increase in the number of female policies. And this will come to bite women on the *** badly, as more women get their own policies more women will have to claim. And more men will be second drivers on womens cars so will result in more claims by women. This is the opposite case currently with men - many women wives, daughters are second drivers on mens polocies but now the opposite will start to happen.

    5) there are significantly fewer young female drivers then men and women on average pass later on (and look at above posts to see poor female pass rates!) young drivers = more crashes, ONCE AGAIN This is rapidly changing.

    6) Men drive larger engine sizes and better specs of cars. There is the issue of men getting paid more but in general this is also down to gender differences, women spend more on hair products then men (nothing to do with income) so it could be down to the fact men just want better and faster cars.

    7) As a result of this men claims cost much more then womens, as their cars are more expensice, harder to source and find repairs for.

    8) On the extreme end of this men are MUCH more likely to drive high performance cars, modified cars and super/hyper cars. Typical super car companies are over 90% male. How many females do you know you OWN a ferrari, lambo, porsche. The only sports cars women have are lower grade "faux" sports cars like the audi tt or low level porsches.

    Obviously you can see the nightmare for insurers, when a $.1.5 million Ferrari Enzo or $1 Mclaren F1 crashes can't you? Many of the speeding offences and deaths on roads are from high performance, modiefied or supercars which obviously men own infintely more times then women (espeically in the very high end bugattis, aeros, ultimate range ferraris or lambos simply because men like these cars just like women like makeup and also cos men earn more.

    Finally as i said men have completly different driving habits such as not taking kids, more milage, longer journies, more expensive cars bigger cars etc. as I have shown with driving stats and the pass rates (see previous posts) Men have better driving skills and on the extreme scale this results in men and men only winning fomula 1,2,3, gp2, lemans, rallying, stunt driving etc. YOU WONT SEE MANY WOMEN TRYING TO QUICKLY DO THAT THREE POINT turn on the main road or drive 150 miles down a country lane - simply becase THEY ARE NOT CONFIDENT ENOUGH IN THE OWN SKILLS TO DO SO!! and yes partly because they are more likely to have children passengers, eldrely.

    • Post Points: 65
  •  Sat, Jan 12 2008, 4:14 PM

    Re: Women drive a good deal on insurance

    Its legal sexism when men have to pay more just because men make more claims.

    You dont see different races paying different premiums so why should different sexes pay different premiums.

    If the stats could prove a certain race accounts for more accidents and claims can you really see insurers trying to charge them more just because they are of that certain race.

    What about the typical 35 year old bloke with 18 years claim free driving ,why should he pay more than the same typical woman just because he is a man!!.

    It true,change a blokes sex on the quote to a female and i can say in almost all cases the premium goes down.

    Its a scandalous excuse to make men pay more because they supposedly have more accidents,thats always gonna happen as there are more male drivers on the road.

    Message for zoe,women are not better drivers,in fact id say its about equal,most women do less they 10000 miles a year,which is around 200 miles a week or around 25-30 miles a day.

    Men on average do more miles than women so they are bound to have more accidents or collisons with other drivers.

    • Post Points: 5
  •  Sat, Jan 12 2008, 3:51 PM

    Re: Women drive a good deal on insurance

    slowcoach:

    In 2002 - the latest figures available - male drivers committed 94 per cent of driving offences causing death and serious injury (Source: Home Office). Even allowing for the additional amount of male drivers and the additional average mileage per annum - male drivers are still about nine/ten times more likely to kill or permanently cripple or otherwise seriously injure people in road crashes than female drivers. They are also twice as likely to be be killed in road crashes than female drivers.

    In 2002 male drivers also committed 97 per cent of dangerous driving offences, 89 per cent of drink or drug driving offences, 85 per cent of careless driving offences, 83 per cent of speeding offences, and 84 per cent of offences involving neglect of traffic signs and directions and of pedestrian rights (Source: Home Office). These figures were much the same in previous years, and will no doubt continue to be much the same in following years.

    In 2006 - the latest figures available - there were 3,172 road deaths, 28,673 serious injuries and 226,559 minor injuries (Source DfT).

    The anti-camera propagandists would have people believe that the main cause of fatal and serious injury road crashes is inattention and driver error, but does it seem likely that male drivers are nine/ten times more inattentive than female drivers or nine/ten more times prone to driver error, or could it be that male drivers - but by no means all - tend to drive faster and more aggressively than female drivers? We all know the answer of course!

    Since posting the above earlier today I have - by chance - come across more recent figures regarding driving offences. As you can imagine, I have been somewhat mystified during the past couple of years or so as to why more recent figures for driving offences have not been published by the Home Office. Now I know the reason why they hadn't! Because they are now published by the Ministry of Justice!

    The latest figures available are in fact for 2005, and are more or less identical to the figures for 2002 which I quoted above. Of the twenty-five offences listed, male drivers committed 88 per cent of them, including 92 per cent for 'Vehicle or part in dangerous or defective condition' and 89 per cent for 'Motorway offences (other than speeding)'.

    • Post Points: 5
Page 1 of 2 (27 items)   1 2 Next >