There is a scheme for young drivers that manages the insurance risk. I do have an interest in the scheme but also a passion for keeping young drivers and their passengers safe. The risk is managed by supplying newer cars with higher safety ratings with better controls, power steering, ABS brakes etc and insisting upon additional driver training such as Pass Plus. The insurance premiums are, however, a fraction of market rates
Taking a logical approach, a driving instructor teaches a pupil in a new car with modern technology and the chances are all the controls do what they should. After passing a test which is taken in relatively benign circumstances, the young driver now has the ability to drive any heap. Any 10 year old car will still be relatively expensive as they carry small car premiums but they handle like puddings compared to a new car and that is if everything still works properly. Put a few friends in and that pudding turns into blancmange, with an inexpreienced driver at the wheel.
Who teaches young inexperienced drivers to drive these older cars? Any youngster in any era is/was tempted to push the boundaries, some learn by their mistakes, some are risk adverse, others are not so lucky. Of course older drivers will be a better insurance risk, they have a more miles under their belt.
Government stats show that 1 in 5 young drivers will crash in their first 12 months behind the wheel, on this managed scheme it is closer to 1 in 100. Whilst there have been a few write offs out of the 600+ cars on the scheme, only 4 were the fault of the young drivers, with no injuries or worse. In one of those the father is on record as saying that his son and four passengers would not be alive had the car a few years older, such was the severity of the crash As it was they were wearing seat belts, the 6 air bags deployed and they just opened the doors and stepped out.
OK this scheme won't be right for everyone as it involves a new or nearly new car and economic reality comes into the equation but there will come a point where young driver insurance will be so high that managing the risk will be the only way forward. As from tomorrow, one large company no longer insures under 25 yo, even as a named driver - other companies will follow, reducing the options and this will send premiums up for this sector.