Hi JoSa,
I've got a Mac at home using a BT broadband connection and (touch wood) never had any problems - although it helps to know what you're doing from a technical point of view (doesn't it always!)
As far as recommending another provider goes, O2 get positive reviews on a regular basis (no doubt someone will now prove me entirely wrong!) but as you've already pointed out, it's about knowing what you need and what you don't require - such as TV, phone etc - plus things like speed, the quality/speed of your router and whether you're using it over a wireless connection. If your router is one that BT provided free of charge, depending on its age it could be affecting the speed. IIRC, MacBook's use wireless N and some older router's don't support it.
I hope that helps. Does anyone else have any helpful suggestions?
Cheers,
Graeme Delap, Community Editor,
graeme.delap@moneysupermarket.com
Nominate your Community Star:
Community Stars 2009