Hi there ty4that,
My advise is to look at the web site & select the package you need, add it all up & if its what you fancy try it. Talk Talk is probabley more price competetive but it depends on the whole service element etc that you get from the company & ISP you choose to go with.
Since i started with MAAF i can honestley say i have had minimal issues & if i have had any help from the support team & customer service they have been very quick to sort any probs out.
My line rental is £9.99, Broadband £13.99 5gb ( got a discount in 2nd year) & i get free eve/weekend calls package with the line rental, my call costs are around £2.50 per month all prices are inc VAT.
If you are happy & dont have any probs with your present ISP dont change but if your not A Breath Of Fresh Air with MAAF could be what you need....
Keep me posted Tony T