Opt for "nearly new"
Why?
New cars will depreciate a minimum of 17.5% as soon as you drive out the showroom.
A nearly new car (say one year old) will stilll have the benifits of a new car, eg, no MOT for another 2 years and still under manufacturers warranty for a minimum of two years.
Recently I bought a new car and I had to pay a tax of £50 over and above the £400 road tax. This was a one off tax for the new car so I would think this would not be required with a nearly new one!
At the end of the day it will be new to you. If you will be financing the car then you will have a shorter term to pay the balance. Or, you could still spend the same amount of money that you would have done on the new car and buy a better model?
Or, keep the money you saved and go on a wee holiday.