home
in

Employer being too demanding?

Last post Fri, Sep 25 2009, 9:49 PM by seth82. 2 replies.
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  Fri, Sep 25 2009, 9:49 PM

    Re: Employer being too demanding?

    Hi,

    thank you for your response. The problem is, that I have already tried to contact HSE as I know the 1974 Health & Safety Act a bit. But the response from them was very unclear and not specific, i.e. - it didn't really help to sort my issue out. You can have a look on it here on pastebin, it's almost 2 pages long, but it's not helpful. I can gather almost all the information mentioned there from Internet almost any time. I can try to contact ACAS, but I'm already loosing hope...

    • Post Points: 5
  •  Fri, Sep 25 2009, 9:29 PM

    Re: Employer being too demanding?

    Seth

    An employer can only require you to carry out their reasonable instructions. What they are asking you to do, is not reasonable and you should get some advice.

    The HSE might be interested in looking into this as there does appear to be Health & Safety issues. Can they contact your employer, without them being aware that you have advised about this situation. See http://www.hse.gov.uk/workers/responsibilities.htm

    You could also contact ACAS to find out about your general employment rights. http://www.acas.org.uk/index.aspx?articleid=1461

    Huckster

    • Post Points: 20
  •  Fri, Sep 25 2009, 9:10 PM

    Employer being too demanding?

    Hi,

    I work as a Parking Host (according to our company, it's cleaner's job, customer service job, security job and cashier's job in one) in Yorkshire. Our company operates 3 different car parks in the city centre and I work in one of them. There was a change in working pattern of all the Parking Hosts in our town last year, after (verbal) agreement accepted by us and the company, we basically switched to 4 on - 4 off shift pattern, with four 12-hour shifts at work and 4 days off.

    When we made this agreement, we accepted the company's scheme, which defines all 3 car parks in a town as a Cluster - that means, that if there are two of us working on our car park in one day and something happens in another one (somebody will get suddenly sick, etc.), one of has HAS to cover the affected site without questioning it.

    So let's get closer to my problem: What is happening now - the company is trying to save every penny on it's staff (they make huge profits every year anyway) and it dismissed 2 or 3 Parking Hosts. The situation now is, that every time one of us is either sick or on holiday, one of the car parks is unmanned and has to be covered by someone from another site.

    But our company stepped to another solution - they want us to cover 2 car parks at once. And how it is supposed to work? Well - right now I'm on my four 12-hour nightshifts in one car park, which is busy approximately until midnight. I also have an emergency response mobile phone from another carpark (which is approximately in 1 mile distance from my workplace) and my company wants me to WALK over there, DURING THE NIGHT by myself, if a customer needs sorting out. They also want me do go over there to do some duties. Now this town has a very busy nightlife, thanks to massive amount of students.

    I am just wondering - do they have the right to ask me to leave my original workplace, have a 15-minute long walk to another site across the whole Leeds city centre? Even if I am supposed to be a part of a cluster, do they have the legal right to ask for such things? Isn't that a breach either of my contract, or Health&Safety Act, or both? Is there any legal advice I can get easily and personally (I honestly don't know, if Citizen Advice Bureau can handle this)?

    They do ask for another things that are not in our contracts, but I still honestly believe, that they cannot do this. I am not even saying about the 'customer service' I am supposed to provide to the customers on our carpark, because everytime I leave, it takes at least 15 minutes to get back - if something happens on my carpark and it needs to be sorted out by myself personally, the poor customer must wait until I arrive - that's the strategy of my employer.

    I would like to write a grievance about this matter, but I honestly don't know, if such fight does make sense. I am a full-time international student of European Law at university (and thus I am not much acquainted with UK laws) and I am not the only one of the Parking Hosts, who complains about the manners of our employer. But it seems, that I am the only one, who is trying to sort this out, as my colleagues are too afraid to support me without showing them a proof, that we CAN actually change something.

    So, please - if there is someone, who can help me with this case, I would be happy if You offered me any solution to this, legal advice, acts and laws dealing with such matters, and so on.

    Thank You.
    • Post Points: 20