I am a mortgage broker. I worked for 15 years within an estate agency.
My wife is a nationally respected conveyancing solicitor of 19 years in the industry.
When we move we will use an estate agent. In fact every time we've sold we've used an estate agent, even investment properties.
Why? 2 reasons.
Some transactions proceed smoothly and the estate agent will regard himself as having earned some easy money. Many transactions don't proceed smoothly and the estate agent earns every penny of his fee*. Selling privately - you might get lucky, you might not. You mainly hear about the 'got lucky's' who've saved themselves several thousands. By default you won't hear about the failures.
* Obviously in both cases the estate agent won't get any credit, but there are many middle scenerios where the agent has nipped a problem in the bud or held a chain together where it would have otherwise fallen apart where again, they rarely get credit.
The other reason - this is tricky to explain. I want to sell my house for the highest figure possible, but that figure isn't set by me, nor the estate agent, it's set by the small army of buyers out there looking for houses.
So, what I need to do is expose my house to the most people possible so that I stand the maximum chance of finding the person willing to spend a little bit extra to live here.
That, in general is the local estate agent with the best reputation and the most sold boards out. They must also promote their properties on the largest property website since I know many people who only look on that site, but I know no-one who only looks at any other site.
So, these 'sell your house privately' websites are good for choice and it's fair to say there are enough chancers in the estate agent community to drive people into selling privately.
But in summary I feel to get a more secure sale and increase the chance of getting the maximum price for the house the best local estate agent is your man.
I know people who have made sucessful private sales at good prices. I know people who have sold their house privately, it gone wrong, then gone to an estate agent whose sold the house for £5000 more and only charged £2500. There will be examples of every scenario and m,any stories of bad agents or 'percieved to be bad agents'.
If you want my personal strategy for next time: I know the agent i will use, he's got the best board presence in the town. I will offer him 1% up to £X,000's and 5% of everything above that figure. I may even offer him hit bonuses for very high sale prices. I'll make it worth his while to get a high price and see how it goes.
Doesn't it seem odd that we have a very valuable thing and without fail we want to incentivise the man selling it to "get rid of it cheap" by paying him the lowest %age possible - advertising/websites/details all cost him money. If we aren't giving it to him he will want to keep his costs down.
Just my little bug bear. Sorry to harp on.
Adrian
Oh - here's a thought.
'The estate agent was a crook, he made me pay too much for my house, I'll never use him again'
Good reasoning or bad reasoning?